¿Puede la IA elegir entre dos niños para salvar ?
Vota — luego lee lo que encontró nuestro editor y los modelos de IA.
No como un experimento mental. Como una decisión real, con ambas opciones frente a ti.
Background
The ability of AI to make ethical decisions, particularly in situations involving human life, is a highly debated and complex topic. Currently, AI systems are not capable of making moral judgments in the same way humans do, and they lack the emotional and social context to fully understand the implications of such decisions. Researchers are exploring the development of AI systems that can learn from human values and ethics, but these systems are still in their infancy and face significant challenges in replicating human moral reasoning. The idea of an AI being forced to choose between two children to save is often used as a thought experiment to highlight the difficulties of programming AI to make ethical decisions.
AI systems currently lack the moral and ethical reasoning capabilities to make such a difficult and emotionally charged decision as choosing between two children to save. While AI can process and analyze vast amounts of data, it does not possess the same emotional intelligence, empathy, or moral compass as humans, which are essential for making such a decision. The current state of the art in AI focuses on optimizing outcomes based on data-driven objectives, but it does not account for the complex moral and ethical considerations involved in this scenario. As a result, AI is not capable of making a decision that would be considered acceptable by human standards in this context.
— Enriched May 9, 2026 · Source: MIT Press — Status checked on May 11, 2026.
Sugerir una etiqueta
¿Falta un concepto en este tema? Sugiérelo y el administrador lo revisará.
Estado verificado por última vez en September 25, 2026.
Galería
¿Puede la IA elegir entre dos niños para salvar?
Existen demostraciones limitadas — pero el panel no fue unánime.
But the data is real.
The Case File
Across 26 sessions, 53 jurors have heard this case. Combined tally: 1 YES · 4 ALMOST · 47 NO · 1 IN RESEARCH.
Note: cumulative includes older juror opinions. The current session tally above is the live verdict.
By a vote of 0 — 1 — 0, the panel returns a verdict of CASI, with verdict confidence of 73%. The court so orders. Verdict upgraded from prior session.
"Language models can output a choice for moral dilemmas, but lack reliable, universally accepted decision-making capability."
Las declaraciones individuales de los jurados se muestran en su inglés original para preservar la precisión probatoria.
Lo que el público piensa
No 58% · Sí 13% · Quizás 29% 219 votesDiscusión
no comments⚖ 26 jury checks · más reciente hace 1 día
Cada fila es una comprobación de jurado independiente. Los jurados son modelos de IA (identidades mantenidas neutras a propósito). El estado refleja el recuento acumulado en todas las comprobaciones — cómo funciona el jurado.
Más en Ethical
¿Puede la IA redactar solicitudes finales convincentes para la eutanasia humana ?
¿Puede la IA emitir un juicio moral en un escenario complejo del mundo real ?
¿Puede la IA construir una silla funcional a partir de un árbol, con herramientas manuales ?